Judge María Afiuni's Decision Cited UN Working Group Opinion

palacio121509.jpgAs many readers are aware, late last week the Venezuelan Judge Maria Lourdes Afiuni ordered the conditional release of Eligio Cedeño to stand trial in freedom.  Immediately afterward she was unjustly arrested, and attacked on live television by President Hugo Chavez, who called for the maximum penalty of 30 years be applied against her - a very abnormal and outrageous action for a president to take against the presumed innocence of a citizen.  What has not been made public until now, was that during the hearing in which Judge Afiuni delivered her decision, she was provided with an opinion by the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention of the United Nations, which declared that Cedeño's incarceration was unlawful.  See below the latest press release detailing the events.

Judge's Decision to Release Eligio Cedeño Based on Opinion of United Nations Working Group

Jailing of Judge María Lourdes Afiuni Shows Lack of Judicial Independence, says Lawyer

CARACAS, Dec. 15, 2009 - On Thursday, Dec. 10, the Venezuelan political prisoner Eligio Cedeño was conditionally released following an order issued by Judge María Lourdes Afiuni. Within minutes of granting Cedeño's conditional release, Judge Afiuni was arrested by officers from Venezuela's intelligence police (DISIP), the ruling was reversed by another judge of the same court, and a new arrest warrant was issued for Cedeño.


Defense lawyers present at the hearing have affirmed that Judge Afiuni's decision was based primarily on an Opinion adopted on September 1, 2009 by the U.N. Working Group on Arbitrary Detention. The Opinion states that, "The deprivation of freedom of Mr. Eligio Cedeño is arbitrary, since it violates the provisions of articles 9, 10 and 11 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and 9, 10 and 14 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights." The U.N. Working Group transmitted its detailed Opinion on the Cedeño case to the Government of Venezuela earlier this year, and requested that Cedeño be granted "provisional freedom until the end of the trial." The court was never informed of the U.N. Working Group's Opinion through Venezuelan government channels. The document was provided to Judge Afiuni only by Cedeño's defense counsel, for the preliminary hearing.

"There was a time that judges who failed to follow Chávez's instructions risked being removed from the bench," noted London-based attorney Robert Amsterdam, one of Cedeño's lawyers. "With the arrest of Judge Afiuni last week, Chávez wrote an obituary for freedom in Venezuela. Judicial independence had been on life support but, sadly, it is now officially dead."

The day after Judge Afiuni's arrest, President Hugo Chávez appeared on national television to denounce Judge Afiuni as a crook ("bandida"), claiming that her decision had been pre-arranged with Cedeño's lawyers. President Chávez also instructed the Attorney General, the President of the Supreme Court and the members of the Legislature to ensure that Judge Afiuni is convicted and sentenced to 30 years in prison.

The next day, Judge Afiuni - who had been assigned at random to manage the proceedings in Cedeño's case - was indicted on charges of corruption, accessory to an escape, criminal conspiracy and abuse of power. She was transferred to a severely overcrowded women's prison outside of Caracas (Instituto Nacional de Orientación Femenina "INOF"), where she is believed to be among the general prison population, some members of which she herself may have sentenced. Further, Judge Afiuni has been denied the right to a public defender.

The military police have also detained the Cedeño defense lawyer José Rafael Parra Soluzzo, and have held him under arrest without charges at the military intelligence headquarters (DIM). The arrests of Afiuni and Parra have provoked public outrage: the Caracas College of Lawyers has published a statement condemning both unlawful detentions, and demanding immediate release.

Cedeño had been held for more than 34 months without a trial in the DISIP headquarters in connection with his alleged participation in an improper currency exchange transaction. The applicable law, however, permits no more than two years of pretrial detention. At the Dec. 10 hearing, prosecutors failed to attend court for the second time in one week, and defense counsel applied for conditional release as allowed under Article 264 of Venezuela's Code of Criminal Procedure. Judge Afiuni's decision to release Cedeño was expressly authorized in Article 264, which requires control judges to review periodically all pretrial preventive measures and grants judges complete discretion to modify pretrial detention for less stringent measures.

More information on the Eligio Cedeño case can be found on www.eligiocedeno.com and www.robertamsterdam.com.

###

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://www.robertamsterdam.com/cgi-bin/mt4/mt-t.cgi/18719

1 Comments

If there's one guiding nike shoes principle to writing good articles, this is it, and it isn't as easy as it nike tailwind sounds. The temptation to turn article writing into a numbers game is tantalizing and seductive. Most of us fall mens air max 2010 for it, especially when we're just starting out. There's also an element of competition involved. For example, many online nike air 2010 marketing forums will have multiple threads at any given time with members bragging about how many 2010 womens nike air max articles they can write in a day. The notion that it's all about quantity nike air max 2009 seeps into a lot of minds this way. You have to work hard to avoid letting this take hold.Writing a good nike air max 2009 womens, quality article takes time. It requires effort and discipline. In other words, it's not nike air max 2009 mens sexy.' It's hard, 'nose to the grindstone' work. But the motivation comes from understanding that the commitment to authoring only good mens nike air max 95 shoes articles pays large dividends over the long haul. You will gain an impressive reputation as a writer. Your mens nike air max 90 site will gain authority in your niche. Your articles will be picked up by womens air max 90 scores of others . Your RSS feed will be posted to more air max shoes blogs.

Leave a comment


Watch us on YouTube

About this Blog

The objective of Venezuela Report is to provide quality information, reports, news, translations, and original opinion and analysis articles in both English and Spanish, with the goal of bridging the significant gap between the political dialogue in Venezuela and the rest of the world, and raising awareness of the problems and challenges we see in both the legal system and governing model. ...

Continue reading...

My Firm